No JoAnn’s? Amish Country Still Delivers

JoAnn’s Is Gone. Your Next Supply Run Is Better.

When JoAnn Fabrics disappeared, it wasn’t only the loss of a store. It was the loss of an experience: a familiar stop where sewers, quilters, and crafters could take their time, get inspired, and walk out ready to make something.

The good news is that in Amish Country, shopping for supplies still feels like part of the craft. Instead of one big-box stop, you’ll find stores made for makers. There’s lots to browse and staff who know what you’re working on and can point you in the right direction.

Sewing, quilting, and handwork are woven into the culture here, so the stores reflect that. You’ll find quality materials, the basics you reach for all the time, and staff who can troubleshoot with you. And because you’re in Amish Country, the supply run comes with the rest of the outing too: other small shops, good food, and plenty of reasons to make a day of it.

Here are the shops that don’t just fill the JoAnn’s gap, they beat it

Zinck’s Fabric Outlet comes close to the big-box selection, but with better deals and a true treasure-hunt feel. People mention the huge variety and low prices, and you can easily walk out with more than you planned because there’s always something unexpected on the shelves. If you like to browse and stock up, start here.

Plaid Sheep Company leans into the inspiration side of shopping. The displays are set up to spark ideas, and the selection goes beyond basics with kits, patterns, and specialty materials like wool and homespuns. People talk about how welcoming it feels and how often they leave with a new project in mind, not just supplies.

Miller’s Dry Goods is one of the main supply stops in Amish Country, and it shows. People mention the depth of selection and the helpful staff, especially when you’re deciding between options or trying to solve a specific problem in the middle of a project. Even if quilting isn’t your focus, it’s an easy replacement for the JoAnn’s run because you can cover a lot in one stop and leave with materials and tools that fit what you’re making.

Lone Star Quilt Shop replaces a nice part of the JoAnn’s run: walking in, getting your bearings fast, and having someone nearby who can answer a question if you need it. Reviews mention friendly staff and a strong selection, and it’s a good stop even if quilting isn’t your main thing. If you want quality materials, solid tools, or you’re looking at machines and want to see options up close before you buy, this is the place for you. 

The Rural Thimble is a private retreat house in Charm designed for sewing and craft weekends, with sleeping space for a group and a spacious, well-lit work area so everyone can spread out and work comfortably. The best part is the location. You’re steps from Miller’s Dry Goods, so you can grab what you forgot, pick up what you need next, then go right back to making. The setting is pure Amish Country too, with country views and buggies passing by, so it feels like a getaway.

For more things to do beyond the shops, head to https://www.visitamishcountry.com. You’ll find ideas for attractions, places to eat, and seasonal events. You can also browse lodging options and build a simple plan for your day or weekend.