Experience the arts in Amish Country, Ohio

Amish Country has a reputation for tradition—but there’s more happening here than most people realize. One moment you’re catching an original musical; the next, you’re walking a wooded trail filled with sculptures. You can catch a comedy show or explore a 10-foot-tall mural in the round that spans 500 years of history. Art, performance, and storytelling all live here. You just have to know where to look.
If you're planning a trip and want something beyond buggies, here are seven places that’ll give you something to talk about on the way home.

“Road to Damascus” at the Ohio Star Theater

Sugarcreek, OH

If you're drawn to stories that stir the heart as much as they entertain, Road to Damascus is worth your time. The Ohio Star Theater’s first original musical brings the Biblical story of Saul—later known as Paul—to the stage with powerful storytelling and strong visuals. From the moment the lights come up, you're transported into a world of vibrant sets, dramatic lighting, and live animals that help bring the biblical era to life. The show follows Saul’s dramatic transformation, offering a moving portrayal of faith, redemption, and courage.

Amish Country Theater Resident Shows

Walnut Creek, OH

There’s no better place for a night of good, clean fun than the Amish Country Theater. This year’s lineup includes two new shows—Haystack Hilarity and All-Quaked Up—each packed with silly characters, family-friendly jokes, and just enough local flavor to keep things interesting. You’ll meet fan favorites like the Jonas Brothers (no, not those ones), Fannie Mae, and other small-town personalities who always seem to find themselves in over their heads. It’s the kind of show where everyone’s in on the joke, and you’ll walk out smiling.

Open Air Art Museum at The Inn at Honey Run

Millersburg, OH

This one’s for the quiet wanderers. Set on the quiet grounds of the Inn at Honey Run, the Holmes County Open Air Art Museum offers something rare: a chance to experience art without walls. This wooded trail winds through meadows and forest, with large-scale sculptures and site-specific installations placed along the path. Each piece responds to the natural landscape—some subtly, some boldly—creating a thoughtful balance between creativity and creation. It’s a peaceful place, easy to explore at your own pace, and perfect for anyone who appreciates beauty, reflection, and a quiet moment outdoors.

Berlin Creek & Blue River Galleries

Berlin, OH

Berlin Creek & Blue River Galleries feature work from over 200 American artists—including well-known names like P. Buckley Moss and Thomas Kinkade—alongside a thoughtfully curated selection of original paintings, pottery, hand-blown glass, and artisan-made jewelry.
Whether you’re an experienced collector or just someone who appreciates beautiful things, there’s a lot to take in here. The galleries are warm and welcoming, with knowledgeable staff who care deeply about the work they show. And if you find something you love, their custom framing is worth the stop all on its own—creative, detailed, and recognized for its craftsmanship.

Holmes Center for the Arts

Millersburg, OH

The Holmes Center for the Arts plays an important role in the cultural life of the region. Throughout the year, it offers a full calendar of concerts, performances, and classes—from ballet and theater to painting, voice, and instrumental music. While many of the programs support local students and families, visitors are welcome to attend public events and performances.
Whether you’re catching a seasonal concert or exploring the gallery space, this is a chance to see the local community at its most creative. The Center is also helping raise the next generation of artists and performers—something worth supporting, and something meaningful to witness while you’re here.

Behalt: An Amish & Mennonite Heritage Center

Berlin, OH

Behalt isn’t just a museum—it’s the heart of Amish and Mennonite storytelling. At its center is a massive 10-foot-tall, 265-foot-long cyclorama painting that sweeps through more than 500 years of Anabaptist history, from the Reformation in Europe to life in Holmes County today. The detail is extraordinary, but what makes it truly moving is its story of conviction, persecution, migration, and enduring faith.

Guided tours bring the painting to life, offering insight into the values that continue to shape the Amish and Mennonite communities. For many, this is the most meaningful stop of their visit—an experience that stays with you long after you leave.
Planning Your Trip

What makes these experiences special isn’t just the talent or the setting, it’s the feeling that you’ve stumbled onto something real – a community that values creativity for the way it brings people together. 

If you really want to take it all in, stay the night—there’s more to see when you’re not in a hurry.